The Tribes|About Us|Webboard|Guest Book|Thai 
Karen Hmong Mien Lahu Lisu Akha Kachin
Daraang Mlabri          

Wow. I mean, wow. I knew the song had some pretty offensive imagery, but this video borders on the offensiveness of that "Respect" advertisement by Land Rover. I mean it is just wrong (either factually or morally) in so many ways: the girl's superimposed suggestive dancing, the hyperactive Robert Palmer girls behind her, her red outfit (red is symbolic of death for Hmongs), and, most importantly, the two kids represented as Hmong are not Hmong at all but are smaller-than-average Thai kids dressed up in cheap knock-offs of Hmong clothing probably purchased at the Chiang Mai Night Bazaar.

And what school is going to have only two Hmong kids and allow those kids to come to school not dressed in their school uniform?

Now, before you go thinking that I am a fuddy-duddy, I will admit again that the song and video have their charms. The makers of this video try their hardest to create cute faux-Hmong kids. But the issue here is not whether or not the kids are cute. The issue is when will hilltribe people be accepted as equals in Thailand, and how does this objectification of hilltribe people as "adorable" or "mysterious" others delay the process of that acceptance?

For example, when was the last time you thought of someone as "cute" yet still viewed them as your equal?

On a positive note, I will give credit to the casting department for picking the woman who plays the teacher. She's perfect. She's perfect because by the end of her teaching career, every teacher in up-country Thailand looks exactly like this woman.

Comment 1
Name Post  : Mark C Squire
Email  : 
Comment  :  See ttp://troubledponderings.blogspot.com/2005/01/virtual-hilltribes-political.html for more of this reaction.
Date Post : 28 ¡.¤. 49, Time:14 : 23 : 04

Comment 2
Name Post  : Emberina6: Jon,
Email  : 
Comment  : You are very astute! Thank you very much. I agree fully with your views.
Date Post : 28 ¡.¤. 49, Time:14 : 24 : 11

Comment 3
Name Post  : Rudolf Hessing
Email  : 
Comment  :  Fully agree with Jon
Date Post : 28 ¡.¤. 49, Time:14 : 24 : 26

Comment 4
Name Post  : see yang
Email  : 
Comment  :  well it sounds kute..its nice..
Date Post : 28 ¡.¤. 49, Time:14 : 24 : 40

Comment 5
Name Post  : vang
Email  : 
Comment  : wow! i wish this would world have alot of people like Jon - webmaster, because that person have a kind heart!
Date Post : 31 ¡.¤. 49, Time:22 : 46 : 20

Comment 6
Name Post  : Wlater Soden
Comment  : I just wish that I was 1/2 as smart as most of you people
Date Post : 31 µ.¤. 49, Time:03 : 28 : 16


Name :
E-mail :
Comment :
    

Museum : About Us: Webboard : Guest Book : Contact Us :
Designed by Bannok "The Mirror Foundation"
JavaScript Menu By Milonic.com